Does a Man Have to Be ‘Alpha’?

One wrong turn can turn young men into women-hating machines.

Recently, I came across a video by Andrew Tate in which he says, “You can’t be the kind of man women want you to be unless you’re misogynistic.” Tate is discussing it on a podcast

 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

After I watched the video, my feed was filled with ones where men were talking about asking young men to talk about becoming “high value,” building discipline, making more money, getting stronger, and learning how to “deal with women”.

Another video like this says men are being made weaker through social media. It shows a muscular man working out and calling young men to be stronger.

A few more videos appeared in which Andrew Tate was saying that the number one indicator of a man’s success is his ability to deal with stress. The video has over 39K Likes on Instagram, with some users praying for Tate’s release from jail.

After watching these videos, I noticed how they are being used to turn a man’s loneliness and insecurities into hate towards women.

It starts small, with a fitness influencer in a reel or a post about masculinity, and it builds from there. History proves all it takes is a well-shot frame and a powerful voice to sway a crowd.

A young, lonely, rejected man is often confused about the ideal male image, and the internet is full of people who tell them exactly what’s wrong with their life and who is apparently responsible for it.

These videos don’t begin with something hateful. In the videos I’ve seen, it’s initially about working out, waking up early, building discipline, making money and, in the longer run, being more confident. The problem starts when “work on yourself” turns into “they are responsible for it”.

The more I looked into the manosphere, the more I realised that it’s not just a group of men like Andrew Tate sitting online preaching to men. It’s bigger than that.

It’s an ecosystem of influencers: dating coaches, fitness creators, “alpha” accounts, Red Pill spaces. 


And to be frank, I find things like superbikes, supercars, six-packs attractive. And most of it feels quite natural at this age. I also want to look good, make money and have things that make me feel good.
And that’s probably why this content sells well.

Algo Knows The Frustrations 

What I felt was dangerous about entering the manosphere is how ordinary it can feel at first. I might watch a fitness video; the algorithm then gives me productivity advice. Then slowly the content shifts and I start getting videos on confidence, dating advice, and becoming more attractive. Before I realise it, I’m not watching videos anymore. I’m absorbing a way of thinking that changes how I see women, relationships and even myself.

Men don’t necessarily look for misogyny; we go for an explanation.

Young men can stumble into this content while looking for something as ordinary as dating tips, workout advice or crypto tips. And that’s what makes it tricky.

Most people don’t fall into this rabbit hole by searching for an ideology. They are just searching for help.

This is when someone appears on the screen as a messiah, saying, “Yo! Bro. I know what’s wrong”. It can attract him, right?

Something is Wrong with Your Life

The greatest trick these influencers pull is taking any complicated problem and giving it one stop-solve-for-all explanation.

If the man is unemployed, he lacks discipline. If he is single, maybe he is not “high value”. If he’s insecure, he needs more muscle.

Yes! Exercise does help; having money gives us security, confidence and social skills can make life easier. But human beings are not equations where we put in the right amount of money, muscle and confidence and automatically get love, respect or happiness in return. We can do everything right and still face rejection, feel lonely and struggle with self-doubt. That’s life. Not everything can be optimised, and not every relationship follows a formula.

Photograph: Walter Weekes/X

Someone to Blame

And this is how the modern ecosystem run by the Internet targets women and modern society.

A man’s personal problems suddenly become a part of a gender war.

A man was rejected because women want only “chads”. They can’t find a partner because women are independent now. They are unhappy because women have unrealistic standards. This is where the “bros” turn a man’s insecurity into evidence. Every bad experience is presented as a confirmation.

All women are being presented as shallow.
Modern relationships are broken.
One woman behaved badly, so feminism is to blame.

When we scroll through YouTube Shorts and Insta Reels, the algorithm quickly picks up on our watch time and pivots the feed straight into the videos that frame modern dating as a zero-sum game where women are the liars designed to exploit men. The red-pill narrative insists women are hypergamous “gold-diggers” who will mock a man when he is broke, only to come running to him when he builds wealth and status.

It gets worse from there. Rape gets brushed off, women get objectified, and “men’s rights” groups pop up. But they aren’t fighting for men’s rights. They’re fighting against women.

Walter Weekes with Alex Morgan (Photograph: Walter Weekes/X)

Closer home, take the Save Indian Family Foundation. It started in 2005 as an NGO against the misuse of dowry laws and calls itself a men’s rights group. Now it’s all over online forums. It opposed the 2022 petition to criminalise marital rape and backed a marriage strike.

One post on their own website, “How to Finish off #MeToo Movement and Save Lives?”, tells readers to go after the people behind the movement aggressively. It calls feminists “feminazis” and terrorists, says mentally unstable women will do anything, and wants the movement ended. Real honourable men.

The bros on the Internet provide endless anecdotes to support their conclusions. That’s how the foundations for the resentment are laid.

And suddenly masculinity comes with a scoreboard… money, muscle, status, sex and dominance, and there is no end to it.

Cashing in on Loneliness

The manosphere doesn’t always tell lonely men to solve loneliness; it gives loneliness an identity.

A man is not lonely; he is “awake”.

He is not rejected; it’s the system that is rigged.

He is not insecure; he simply doesn’t understand “female nature”.

For me, the central question is who gets to explain why men are struggling. Men are lonely; that’s for sure in an argument. Men and women both are struggling economically; this is also a problem.

The blame game might be a way out to satisfy a man emotionally and to put his anger somewhere; there’s also money in that anger.

Courses, coaches, online communities turn male insecurity into business, but the frustration doesn’t necessarily come from the influencers. They have found a festering wound and are earning from it.

Does a man have to be ‘Alpha’?

I think we need to stop building such dramatic ideas of masculinity.

A man doesn’t have to dominate anyone. He doesn’t need endless girls, or the fanciest car in town, to prove he’s worth something. He can enjoy getting stronger. He can make money because it gives him confidence, and build that confidence until he’s comfortable in his own skin.

The manosphere gets one thing right: young men want direction. They just shouldn’t be getting it from people who profit off their anger.

So when videos like these pop up on my feed, I take a step back and swipe past. I don’t let an online messiah tell me who I am, what I should do with my life, or whom I should hate.